Top 10 Best South Shore Restaurants

The South Shore of Long Island is home to some of the best restaurants in New York. From fine dining establishments with stunning waterfront views, to cozy gastropubs serving elevated pub grub, there is something for every palate. Here are the top 10 best South Shore Restaurants that are worth a visit:

01 – Lakehouse, Bay Shore

Lakehouse is a hidden gem tucked away in the charming village of Bay Shore, which is located on the south shore of Long Island. This intimate eatery has gained popularity for its fantastic New American cuisine and stunning waterfront location. As you enter, you will be greeted with mahogany interiors that exude rustic elegance, creating an atmosphere that is both inviting and cozy.


One of the standout features of Lakehouse is their menu, which features seasonal ingredients and innovative dishes that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Some of their popular dishes include pan-seared duck breast, lobster risotto, and diver scallops with cauliflower puree. The chefs at Lakehouse put a lot of effort into making sure that each dish is prepared to perfection and presented beautifully.

In addition to their delicious food, Lakehouse also boasts an extensive wine list with over 200 selections. Whether you prefer a full-bodied red or a crisp white, you are sure to find something that will pair perfectly with your meal.

Another special feature of Lakehouse is their romantic lakefront dining experience. You can enjoy your meal on a patio overlooking the marina while taking in the scenic views of the water. This setting is perfect for a date night or special occasion. If you’re looking for a more laid-back atmosphere, you can also gather around the outdoor lakeside fire pit with friends and family.

The service at Lakehouse is impeccable, adding to the overall dining experience. The staff are attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu and wine list. They make sure that every guest feels welcome and comfortable throughout their meal.

In summary, Lakehouse offers a unique dining experience that combines exquisite cuisine, a beautiful waterfront location, and top-notch service. It is one of the most romantic restaurants on Long Island’s South Shore, perfect for a special occasion or a memorable night out. If you’re looking for a restaurant with great food, ambiance, and service, Lakehouse is definitely worth a visit.

02 – Salt & Barrel, Bay Shore

Salt & Barrel is a seafood-focused restaurant situated in downtown Bay Shore. The restaurant is housed in a historic 19th-century building and has an inviting atmosphere with a buzzing bar scene. The restaurant’s expansive industrial-chic space features original tin ceilings, exposed brick, and a striking marble bar. This restaurant’s ambiance offers a perfect setting for an enjoyable dining experience.

Salt & Barrel dish

Salt & Barrel is renowned for its extensive raw bar featuring a wide variety of fresh local oysters. The menu also has inventive seafood dishes such as pan-roasted branzino, lobster cobb salad, and sea scallop crudo. These dishes are crafted by the restaurant’s skilled chefs who use only the freshest and finest ingredients to prepare them. Additionally, Salt & Barrel’s bar program features craft cocktails made with homemade syrups and fresh ingredients.

This encourages customers to indulge in delicious drinks that complement their meals. The restaurant’s beer selection is also impressive, with a huge selection of local and imported beers on tap. Moreover, the restaurant has outdoor dining on a patio that overlooks the marina. This provides a beautiful view while enjoying your meal.

Salt & Barrel is a fantastic dining destination on the South Shore. The restaurant’s lively atmosphere, seafood-focused menu, and stellar bar program make it a must-visit spot. The oysters stand out due to their freshness, and the craft cocktails are well-crafted and delicious. The restaurant’s service is impeccable, with friendly staff always ready to assist you. It is an excellent place to spend time with friends and family while enjoying good food and drinks.

03 – SALT, Merrick

SALT is a popular seasonal restaurant situated in Merrick that boasts of a relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere. The restaurant’s airy interior and patio dining overlooking the water set a perfect ambience for a delightful meal with family or friends. SALT’s passion for inventive seafood dishes has made it a favorite neighborhood spot among locals.

SALT's menu

SALT’s menu focuses on locally-sourced seasonal ingredients and sustainably-caught seafood. The restaurant’s use of fresh, high-quality ingredients in their dishes sets them apart from other establishments. Signature dishes like pan-seared scallops, miso-glazed salmon, and lobster mac and cheese are a testament to SALT’s culinary expertise. Their combination of flavors is not only unique but also scrumptious.

Apart from the impressive food offerings, SALT boasts an extensive craft cocktail menu dreamed up by expert mixologists. Their drinks are made with the same attention to detail as their food, making them the perfect complement to any meal. Whether you’re looking for a classic cocktail or something more unique, SALT has got you covered.

Weekend brunch at SALT is also worth mentioning. They offer unique options like crab cake eggs benedict that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. The restaurant’s family-friendly vibe coupled with friendly service creates a welcoming atmosphere that makes SALT the perfect spot for a weekend brunch with loved ones.

04 – The Wharf at Shoal Harbor, Huntington

The Wharf at Shoal Harbor is a fine dining restaurant located atop a bluff that overlooks the stunning Huntington Harbor. The restaurant offers an exquisite dining experience that features locally-sourced seafood specialties. The floor-to-ceiling windows provide panoramic views of the harbor, making it an ideal spot for those who enjoy beautiful scenery.

One of the most notable features of The Wharf is its exceptional menu, which offers seasonally-inspired seafood dishes like butter poached lobster, pan-seared Montauk fluke, and diver scallops with corn risotto. The menu is carefully curated to ensure that only the freshest ingredients are used in each dish. The dishes are beautifully presented and skillfully executed, making every meal a memorable experience.

In addition to the outstanding menu, The Wharf also boasts an extensive selection of Long Island wines and specialty cocktails that are inspired by the seashore. These drinks perfectly complement the delicious seafood dishes, creating a well-rounded dining experience.

The interior design of the restaurant is another standout feature that sets it apart from other fine dining establishments. The sophisticated nautical theme is evident throughout the space, with natural woods and elegant furnishings creating a warm and inviting atmosphere.

During the warmer months, guests can enjoy outdoor patio dining. This provides an opportunity to take in the breathtaking views while enjoying a delicious meal in a serene setting.

Overall, The Wharf at Shoal Harbor provides a magical, romantic dining experience that is unparalleled on the South Shore. From the spectacular sunsets over the harbor to the skillfully executed seafood dishes, this restaurant truly has something for everyone.

05 – The Madison, Huntington

The Madison is a contemporary American restaurant located on New York Avenue in downtown Huntington. The restaurant boasts an upscale yet relaxed vibe and specializes in seasonal, locally-sourced ingredients. It offers a unique dining experience with delicious cuisine and chic interior design.

One of the most appealing features of The Madison is its special menu items. Chef Guy Reuge creates seasonal dishes that are sure to tantalize taste buds. The menu includes options such as seared sea scallops with butternut squash, Long Island duck breast with port wine sauce, and pumpkin ravioli. These dishes are prepared with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and are sure to delight any food lover’s palate.

In addition to the delectable cuisine, The Madison also has an extensive craft cocktail menu overseen by expert mixologists. This ensures that customers can enjoy a delicious drink with their meal or during happy hour. The bar program is meticulously executed, with a wide range of drinks available to suit any taste.

The interior design of The Madison is equally impressive. The restaurant is adorned with crystal chandeliers, leather banquettes, and a copper-topped bar, creating a chic and sophisticated ambiance. The attention to detail in the decor adds to the upscale atmosphere of the restaurant.

During the warmer months, patrons can also enjoy outdoor dining on the patio. This provides a lovely setting for diners to enjoy their meals while soaking up the sun or enjoying the summer breeze.

06 – Crabtree’s Kittle House, Chappaqua

Crabtree’s Kittle House is a historic restaurant located in an old home built back in 1790. The restaurant offers its diners a unique experience by transporting them back in time through its antique decor, intimate fireside dining rooms, and classic American fare.

Crabtree's Kittle House dish

Special Features:

  1. Menu: The restaurant’s menu focuses on comfort food favorites that include dishes like herb-roasted chicken, meatloaf with mushroom gravy, and lobster mac and cheese. Each dish on the menu is prepared to perfection and will leave your taste buds craving for more.
  1. Wine List: Crabtree’s Kittle House boasts of an award-winning wine list with over 400 selections. Whether you’re a seasoned wine connoisseur or just starting out, you’ll find something perfect to complement your meal.
  1. Romantic Dining Rooms: The restaurant has several intimate dining rooms that are furnished with antique furniture, oil paintings, and fireplaces. The ambiance is perfect for couples looking for a romantic dinner or anyone who appreciates historical architecture.
  1. Garden Patio: During warm weather, the restaurant offers outdoor seating on their garden patio. This provides diners with a beautiful view while enjoying their meals in the fresh air.

Overall, Crabtree’s Kittle House is a quintessential fine dining experience. The combination of their old-world charm and hearty yet refined American dishes makes it a memorable evening. The attention to detail in their dishes paired with their award-winning wine list and unique ambiance all contribute to making this restaurant a must-visit for anyone looking for an unforgettable dining experience.

07 – The White Hart, Armonk

The White Hart is an English pub located in a historic New England-style building. The establishment is known for its elevated pub grub and the wide array of beers on tap that it serves. The cozy and laid-back setting makes it a popular neighborhood spot, especially with nightly live music from local performers, mainly acoustic.

One of the standout features of The White Hart is their hearty dishes. Customers can indulge in classic comfort food dishes like fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, chicken pot pie, and bangers and mash. These dishes are prepared to perfection, ensuring customers leave feeling satisfied and content.

Beer lovers will be spoilt for choice as The White Hart boasts 20 beers on tap. Many of these craft brews are locally sourced from New York state breweries, adding a unique touch to the pub experience. The range of beer caters to different tastes, from light lagers to hoppy IPAs and everything in between.

For those who enjoy dining al fresco, The White Hart has a front patio where customers can enjoy their meals while taking in the sights and sounds of the neighborhood. It’s a great place to gather with friends or simply enjoy some alone time over a meal and a drink.

The nightly live music at The White Hart adds an extra layer of entertainment to the experience. The performers are mainly acoustic and provide a relaxed vibe that complements the cozy atmosphere of the pub. It’s the perfect place to unwind after a long day and enjoy some good music with friends.

Overall, The White Hart is an excellent choice for those looking for a traditional English pub experience with a refined twist. The combination of delicious food, a wide range of craft beers, and nightly live music make it a must-visit spot in the neighborhood.

08 – The Twisted Oak, Scarsdale

The Twisted Oak is a gastropub located in Scarsdale that offers an elevated pub experience with its craft beer-focused bar, playful twists on traditional bar fare, and lively atmosphere. The interiors of the establishment are warm and inviting, featuring reclaimed wood, exposed brick, and unique lighting fixtures that create a cozy ambiance for diners.

One of the special features that sets The Twisted Oak apart from other local bars and restaurants is its menu. The establishment’s kitchen team puts playful twists on traditional bar fare, such as pretzel-crusted chicken schnitzel, Korean bbq beef sliders, and buffalo cauliflower tacos. These dishes showcase the creative approach that the gastropub takes when it comes to food.

Another notable feature is the extensive craft beer program, which features 24 rotating taps of local and imported brews. Beer enthusiasts can sample a wide range of options while enjoying their meal or socializing with friends. The selection of whiskeys, wines, and creative house cocktails is also curated, ensuring there is something to suit everyone’s preferences.

The Twisted Oak is also family-friendly during the day, making it an ideal spot for families and groups with children to enjoy a quality meal. As night falls, the establishment transforms into a lively bar scene, attracting a crowd looking for a fun and energetic atmosphere.

This place is an excellent choice for a casual dining experience with friends or alone. The menu offerings are consistently creative and well-executed, ensuring that guests will have a memorable dining experience. The establishment’s first-rate drinks, combined with its lively atmosphere, make it a fun spot to gather and unwind after a long workday or week. Overall, The Twisted Oak is a must-visit gastropub for anyone looking for a best South Shore Restaurants in Scarsdale.

09 – The Tap & Mallet, North White Plains

The Tap & Mallet is a popular neighborhood pub located in North White Plains, known for its warm and friendly atmosphere, All-American cuisine, and impressive selection of craft beers on tap. This establishment has become a favorite among locals looking for a casual place to relax and unwind with friends after work or on weekends.

One of the main draws of The Tap & Mallet is their menu of elevated pub classics. Guests can enjoy a variety of dishes, ranging from chicken pot pie and specialty burgers to fish tacos and short rib poutine. The chefs at Tap & Mallet put a unique spin on these classic dishes, making them stand out from typical pub fare.

In addition to the mouth-watering food, Tap & Mallet also boasts an impressive selection of craft beers on tap. With 30 different beers on offer, including many from hyperlocal NY breweries, beer aficionados are sure to find something to suit their taste. Guests can sample a range of IPAs, stouts, lagers, and other unique brews, making it the perfect spot for beer enthusiasts.

Tap & Mallet offers a cozy bar area equipped with leather couches and TVs showing sports games. The ambiance is relaxed and comfortable, making it the ideal place to catch up with friends over a cold beer and good food. And for those who prefer to enjoy their drinks and meals outdoors, the heated outdoor patio provides a great option.

On Friday and Saturday nights, the pub brings in live acoustic music to entertain guests. This creates a lively and welcoming atmosphere, making it easy to spend hours enjoying good food and drinks while listening to great music.

Overall, The Tap & Mallet is a must-visit for anyone in the North White Plains area looking for a laid-back and approachable gastropub. Whether you’re a fan of craft beer, delicious food, or live music, this establishment has something to offer everyone.

10- The Rarebit, White Plains

The Rarebit is a restaurant located in downtown White Plains that offers a unique dining experience with its focus on seasonal ingredients and creative twists on American cuisine. The restaurant’s modern interior design provides a relaxed upscale setting, making it an excellent choice for a date night or special occasion.

One of the most remarkable features of The Rarebit is that their menu changes frequently based on seasonal produce. This means that guests can expect to find new and exciting dishes every time they visit. Some of the sample dishes include pan-seared bone-in pork chop and shrimp ceviche with watermelon and fresno chili. These dishes showcase Chef Arturo Panades’ innovative approach to cooking and his commitment to sourcing quality ingredients.

Another standout feature of The Rarebit is their creative craft cocktail menu overseen by mixologists. Guests can enjoy a range of refreshing and unique cocktails that are sure to impress. For those who prefer non-alcoholic beverages, the restaurant also offers a selection of homemade sodas and other non-alcoholic drinks.

The restaurant caters to various dietary requirements by offering plenty of gluten-free and vegetarian/vegan options. This makes it an excellent choice for groups with different dietary needs.

The Rarebit’s sophisticated, modern interior design with exposed brick walls creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. The ambiance is perfect for a romantic dinner or an evening out with friends.

The Rarebit is an excellent restaurant that offers a unique dining experience with its focus on seasonal ingredients and creative twists on American cuisine. Chef Arturo Panades’ thoughtful approach to sourcing quality ingredients and putting his own spin on classic American dishes sets this restaurant apart from others. The Rarebit manages to feel upscale but entirely unpretentious, making it an excellent choice for any occasion.

Related article

The Top 10 Best Places to Watch the Sunset in Santa Barbara


The South Shore of Long Island offers an incredible variety of dining destinations to satisfy any palate. From refined seafood restaurants with stunning water views to cozy gastropubs serving inspired fare, these 10 best South Shore Restaurants has to offer. With innovative menus, talented chefs, and lively or romantic atmospheres, each provides a memorable dining experience worth seeking out on your next visit to Long Island’s South Shore.

Other links:

Does it Snow in Spain? A Comprehensive Guide to Snowfall in Spain in 2023

Discovering the Beauty of Huntington Falls: A 2023’s Journey Through Nature and History

Leave a Comment